Using the Evidence EcoSpace to Position Ourselves and Build the Africa We Want

2022-09-20 advocates informs learns news
Using the Evidence EcoSpace to Position Ourselves and Build the Africa We Want
Photo credit: Africa Evidence Network

Background

Over the last ten years, civil society, government and academia have initiated a flurry of activities to strengthen Evidence-Informed Decision Making (EIDM) to reduce poverty and inequality in Africa. Through these activities, EIDM has immensely gained traction, and this has spurred the increasing demand to justify decision-making in various sectors through the use of evidence. As a result of the growing demand for EIDM, new trends have emerged in the African EIDM ecosystem ranging from institutional landscapes to EIDM practices. Analysing these trends within the ecosystem will facilitate the repositioning of actors and evidence-informed repurposing of initiatives to enhance mutual learning, identify new opportunities and develop new ideas about supporting evidence-informed decision-making. The Africa Evidence Network (AEN) hosted a vibrant discussion under its Webinar series that illuminated current trends and how stakeholders may reposition themselves, including mapping the direction of where the AEN is going. The panel consisted of Professor Ruth Stewart, Director, Africa Centre for Evidence (ACE), Mr Kirchuffs Atengble, Director PACKS Africa, Dr Julian Bagyendera, Executive Director, Provide & Equip, Siziwe Ngcwabe, and Dr Carina van Rooyen from ACE respectively facilitated and moderated the session. These discussions are critical in forming the basis for improving the evidence ecosystem and evidence use in Africa.

The African EIDM Ecosystem

Different actors and institutions from various sectors, formal and informal and with varying capacities and resources, are uniquely gelling to produce, translate, and use evidence in Africa. There are nested regional evidence ecosystems within which national ecosystems also exist in this broader evidence ecosystem. The national ecosystems are sector-specific groupings, which are also streamlined to localised ecosystems. This structure is how intricate the EIDM ecosystem is. In analysing trends, this intricacy posed issues of equity and inclusion in light of the diversity associated with the continent's evidence ecosystem. As an evidence network, how can we ensure that we are not neglecting the communities that perhaps don't have the language or the technology to engage and share because they want to learn, and we need to learn from them too?

Identifying Trends and Rethinking Systems

Various trends are emerging in the EIDM ecosystem as a result of both local and global developments. The COVID-19 pandemic brought a new wave of virtual evidence generation and stakeholder engagement, including dissemination. COVID-19 came with shocks, on one hand, a lot of flexibility and more efficient ways of doing things on another. There have been shifts in research methodologies. For example, African evaluations have started incorporating some indigenous and traditional methods. There is a new push to bring in blended methodologies, particularly given the increasing importance of multidisciplinary and interdisciplinary research. The impact agenda has become the next big thing where we are seeing a fundamental shift within the production side towards research impact and the demand side,  particularly the government moving towards linking evidence collation to more strategic knowledge management. The questions arising from these shifts are: What is the evenness in all this? How inclusive are the approaches and methodologies? Which areas should we prioritise, and where have we already done much considering the diversity associated with the African EIDM ecosystem? What does the average African evidence ecosystem represent? These are pertinent questions addressing equity in evidence generation, dissemination, and the capacity to do so. The evaluation community has started to deal with these issues through professionalising the evaluation associations and developing different standards for different countries.

Disconnected Pockets of Innovation and the  Political Economy of Evidence

Although there is still more to do in strengthening various capacities, tangible signs of functional ecosystems with pockets of innovation and exciting initiatives exist. For instance, AFREA initiated the institutionalisation of capacity development to formalise processes and mainstream these for real impact. However, these exciting pockets of innovation are not feeding into each other, and the danger is that the silos will grow deeper and become more ingrained if not addressed. The initiatives are also running at regional, national, subnational and, to some extent, community levels. One of the main challenges with these structures is that at the community level, national and sub-national systems seem to lose focus in conceptualising development interventions, including strengthening policy and practice through EIDM. It is imperative to conceptualise the different experiences and perspectives at various layers to ensure equity. The politics in one country may determine evidence use. It is essential to establish how best to manage politics and ensure that decision-makers use evidence without political interference. One way to go around this challenge is to contextualise EIDM interventions. One question that comes to mind is: How does the African Evidence Ecosystem align with the Global Evidence  Ecosystem? 

There seems to be a big challenge in getting the world to pay attention to the context in Africa. Instead of concentrating on aiding Africa,  development partners should start listening to the innovation and leadership across the continent. There are unique EIDM innovations on the continent, for example, the storytelling traditions used in Cameroon, genuine engagement with local communities with passion and incentives to make a difference to people living in poverty. Many of these examples are extraordinary, and they are very much homegrown. However, persistent unequal power dynamics still make it difficult for Africa to be viewed as equal and not seen with national debt and budget deficit lenses.

Using the informal to formalise and institutionalise EIDM

Even though there are inadequate systems and mechanisms – formal and informal, to fully institutionalise EIDM, their existence is a perfect starting point. Naturally, people are inclined to utilise formal structures because they seem more rational, and everyone wants to associate with them. Still, very often, real change is driven by informal ones. For instance, the previously mentioned storytelling mechanisms where people meet at the community level may be something they are comfortable using. So if that is a mechanism that exists, then we can look at taking advantage of it to drive the evidence agenda. It's a form of redesigning our initiatives to fit our context. It may seem to make sense and rational to be formal. Still, the average citizen, the practitioner, or the different stakeholders may have alternative ways of doing things apart from the formalised practices. And so, when we try to limit ourselves to the formal, which is sometimes characterised by patriarchy, the change we may seek, even if realised, may just be a façade. Authentic change comes through the informal systems, which facilitate equity and inclusivity to accommodate groups often marginalised, such as women and young people, including those living with disabilities. Having capitalised on the informal systems to obtain consensus and buy-in, it becomes possible to institutionalise EIDM by looking at how we move from individuals to teams to organisations and then institutionalise systems. 

Linking Actors,  Roles and Capacities so that they Align to Emerging Trends: The role of the AEN

What is the strategic role of the AEN in the issues above? To improve EIDM design or structural problems across the continent, what areas require attention? The AEN is now a reputable network of individuals promoting the use of evidence and wanting to see real change in people's lives - bringing people together, learning together and sharing experiences. The AEN must pull the different actors and associated competencies from the content together into a viable evidence ecosystem. There may be a concentration of competencies in some countries than in others. Some disciplines or sectors may be doing better than others, so the AEN must use its knowledge base obtained over the years to identify gaps and prioritise and channel resources and capacities to deserving groups, especially at the community level. The AEN is where it is because it has invested in respectful relationships and must continue building around that value system while being more flexible to reinvent itself and remain relevant. 

The EIDM Jigsaw: There is Space for Everyone

What is overarching in the African EIDM ecosystem and the role of AEN are mutual relationships, learning and sharing supported by a diversity of functions and localisation of initiatives, with equity being central in building the connections across individuals, organisations and systems. How can we connect the different learnings emerging from the different contexts? What contributes to successes in some contexts and failures in some other contexts? These are all learnings we need to investigate, and such investigations are going on from the different actors. Different categories of actors are beginning to question their contributions to the ecosystem. It's no longer a simplistic view of evidence producers and evidence users. Even within these traditional groupings, other subcategories like brokers and intermediaries are coming up that we need to investigate and understand. We must carefully consider the actors and role players in our evidence ecosystems whose voices are missing. There's a giant beautiful EIDM jigsaw across all of Africa beckoning for pieces, and each of us must find our space in this jigsaw.

About the author: Ronald Munatsi is the Director of the Zimbabwe Evidence Informed Policy Network (ZeipNET). ZeipNET works to interface evidence and policy through evidence synthesis initiatives, including institutional capacity building focusing on the interface between research and policy with an emphasis on strengthening capacities across individual, institutional and systemic levels.

Disclaimer: The views expressed in published blog posts, as well as any errors or omissions, are the sole responsibility of the author/s and do not represent the views of the Africa Evidence Network, its secretariat, advisory or reference groups, or its funders; nor does it imply endorsement by the afore-mentioned parties.


Related Content

Below is all the content from the Learning Space that have the same tags as this event.

advocates informs learns news
Transformative Action Learning in Navigating the Evidence to Policy Landscape: Lessons from the Ten Years
2022-09-20 advocates informs learns news
Transformative Action Learning in Navigating the Evidence to Policy Landscape: Lessons from the Ten Years
Photo credit: Africa Evidence Network Background The growing interaction among different actors within the evidence-informed decision-making (EIDM) ecosystem in Africa is increasing opportu...
Continue Reading
Using the Evidence EcoSpace to Position Ourselves and Build the Africa We Want
2022-09-20 advocates informs learns news
Using the Evidence EcoSpace to Position Ourselves and Build the Africa We Want
Photo credit: Africa Evidence Network Background Over the last ten years, civil society, government and academia have initiated a flurry of activities to strengthen Evidence-Informed Decision Ma...
Continue Reading
Stepping down as Chair of the AEN and the dawn of a new era
2022-09-19 advocates informs learns news
Stepping down as Chair of the AEN and the dawn of a new era
Photo credit: Africa Centre for Evidence & Africa Evidence Network  If I close my eyes, I transport myself back to 2012 and the first meeting of the Africa Evidence Network after dinner in...
Continue Reading
The 2018 Pretoria Conference, a replay experience
2022-09-08 advocates informs learns news
The 2018 Pretoria Conference, a replay experience
We still remember those three days in Pretoria for EVIDENCE 2018 as if it were yesterday.  160 people from 28 African countries and 6 Western countries from various sectors, including academic...
Continue Reading
Evidence 2016: Jump-off point for work on decolonising evidence-informed decision-making on climate change
2022-08-19 advocates informs learns news
Evidence 2016: Jump-off point for work on decolonising evidence-informed decision-making on climate change
Photo credit: Eric Ngang   I joined the AEN in 2015. I got fully engaged in 2016 when I took part in the conference in Pretoria and presented my work on using local knowledge and practices ...
Continue Reading
EVIDENCE 2022 | SoC Submission Guidelines
2022-08-02 advocates informs learns news
EVIDENCE 2022 |  SoC Submission Guidelines
Thank you for expressing your interest to participate at EVIDENCE 2022. Please read through the submission guidelines before making your content submission for EVIDENCE 2022.
Open Link More Details
EVIDENCE 2022 | #AENis10 Video Submission Guidelines
2022-08-02 advocates informs learns news
EVIDENCE 2022 | #AENis10 Video Submission Guidelines
Thank you for expressing your interest to participate at EVIDENCE 2022. Please read through the submission guidelines before making your content submission for EVIDENCE 2022.
Open Link More Details
EVIDENCE 2022 | AFRICA Talks Video Submission Guidelines
2022-08-02 advocates informs learns news
EVIDENCE 2022 | AFRICA Talks Video Submission Guidelines
Thank you for expressing your interest to participate at EVIDENCE 2022. Please read through the submission guidelines before making your content submission for EVIDENCE 2022.
Open Link More Details
EVIDENCE 2022 | Exhibition Slots Application Guidelines
2022-08-02 advocates informs learns news
EVIDENCE 2022 | Exhibition Slots Application Guidelines
Thank you for expressing your interest to participate at EVIDENCE 2022. Please read through the submission guidelines before making your application for an exhibition slot at EVIDENCE 2022. Please not...
Open Link More Details
AEN June 2022 Newsletter
2022-06-20 advocates informs learns news
Enjoy reading the June edition of the AEN newsletter. Our Africa Evidence feature shares highlights of the recent address by Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala, the first fema...
Open Link More Details
AEN May 2022 Newsletter
2022-05-20 advocates informs learns news
Happy Africa Month! In this month's AEN newsletter, read about expanding engaged research and evidence-use around the world, and receive lessons on how digital technologies can help rese...
Open Link More Details
EVIDENCE 2022 is happening from 19-21 September!
2022-04-25 advocates informs learns news
EVIDENCE 2022 is happening from 19-21 September!
The Africa Evidence Network is proud to announce that EVIDENCE 2022 is happening from 19-21 September 2022. This event is a working meeting on the use of evidence in decision-making in Africa. This ye...
Watch
Exploring relationships and partnerships for enhancing capacities for EIDM in Africa
2022-02-03 advocates africa evidence week 2021 blog events evidence-capacities-webinar-2021 informs learns news
Exploring relationships and partnerships for enhancing capacities for EIDM in Africa
Photo: Africa Evidence Network Evidence Capacities Webinar four participants This blog post is based on the fourth webinar of the Evidence Capacities webinar series, hosted by the Africa Evidence N...
Continue Reading
Africa Evidence Leadership Award 2022 - formulaire de confirmation
2022-02-02 advocates aen award africa evidence leadership award 2022 events evidence informs learns news
Africa Evidence Leadership Award 2022 - formulaire de confirmation
Toute nomination soumise pour le prix Africa Evidence Leadership 2022 doit inclure un formulaire de nomination ET de confirmation.
Open Link More Details
Africa Evidence Leadership Award 2022 - formulaire de nomination
2022-02-02 advocates aela 2022 africa evidence leadership award events evidence informs learns news
Africa Evidence Leadership Award 2022 - formulaire de nomination
Toute nomination soumise pour le prix Africa Evidence Leadership 2022 doit inclure un formulaire de nomination ET de confirmation.
Open Link More Details
#EvidenceCapacities webinar #4: Exploring relationships and partnerships for enhancing capacities for EIDM in Africa
2022-01-20 advocates africa evidence week 2021 events evidence-capacities-webinar-2021 informs learns news
#EvidenceCapacities webinar #4: Exploring relationships and partnerships for enhancing capacities for EIDM in Africa
  The fourth #EvidenceCapacitiesWebinar: Exploring relationships and partnerships for enhancing capacities for EIDM in Africa The Africa Evidence Network secretariat is hosting a series of ...
Watch
AEN January 2022 newsletter
2022-01-20 advocates aen-newsletter 2022 events evidence informs learns news
AEN January 2022 newsletter
The Africa Evidence Network (AEN) is happy to share with you the first AEN newsletter in 2022! The AEN turns ten in 2022! The Africa evidence feature showcases the AEN's ten year celebration plans ...
Open Link More Details
Designing equity into evidence-informed decision-making capacity development in Africa: Experiences from Cameroon
2021-11-05 advocates africa evidence week 2021 events evidence-capacities-webinar-2021 informs learns news
Designing equity into evidence-informed decision-making capacity development in Africa: Experiences from Cameroon
  This blog post is based on the second webinar of the new Evidence Capacities webinar series, hosted by the Africa Evidence Network (AEN). Th...
Continue Reading
AEN October 2021 Special Edition Newsletter
2021-10-20 advocates africa evidence week 2021 events highlights informs learns news
AEN October 2021 Special Edition Newsletter
This month's AEN newsletter is a special edition all about #AfricaEvidenceWeek2021! Missed the engagements? This newsletter is for you to catch up on Africa’s most vibrant evidence event & continue en...
Open Link More Details
#EvidenceCapacities webinar #2: Designing for equity in capacity development for EIDM in Africa: experience sharing from Cameroon
2021-10-14 advocates africa evidence week 2021 events evidence-capacities-webinar-2021 informs learns news
#EvidenceCapacities webinar #2: Designing for equity in capacity development for EIDM in Africa: experience sharing from Cameroon
At this webinar, participants will share their knowledge and experiences in designing capacity development interventions in Cameroon that explicitly address unequal gendered power dynamics and use equ...
Watch
Africa Evidence Week 2021: Emerging EIDM leader _ Akanyinene Obot: why I fell in love with EIDM
2021-10-14 advocates africa evidence week 2021 events evidence informs learns news
Africa Evidence Week 2021: Emerging EIDM leader _ Akanyinene Obot: why I fell in love with EIDM
Mr Akanyinene Obot in conversation with the Africa Evidence Network secretariat on why he fell in love with evidence-informed decision-making (EIDM).
Watch
Africa Evidence Week 2021: Emerging EIDM leader_ Gordon Wanzare: why I fell in love with EIDM
2021-10-14 advocates africa evidence week 2021 events evidence informs learns news
Africa Evidence Week 2021: Emerging EIDM leader_ Gordon Wanzare: why I fell in love with EIDM
Gordon Wanzare is in conversation with the Africa Evidence Network secretariat about why he fell in love with evidence-informed decision-making (EIDM).
Watch
Africa Evidence Week 2021: Emerging EIDM leader_ Likhwa Ncube: why I fell in love with EIDM
2021-10-14 advocates africa evidence week 2021 events evidence informs learns news
Africa Evidence Week 2021: Emerging EIDM leader_ Likhwa Ncube: why I fell in love with EIDM
Likhwa Ncube is in conversation with the Africa Evidence Network secretariat about why he fell in love with evidence-informed decision-making (EIDM).
Watch
Africa Evidence Week 2021: Emerging EIDM leader_Caroline Dusabe: why I fell in love with EIDM
2021-10-14 advocates africa evidence week 2021 events evidence informs learns news
Africa Evidence Week 2021: Emerging EIDM leader_Caroline Dusabe: why I fell in love with EIDM
Ms Caroline Dusabe in conversation with the Africa Evidence Network secretariat on why she fell in love with evidence-informed decision-making (EIDM).
Watch
Africa Evidence Week 2021: Emerging EIDM leader_Charity Chisoro: why I fell in love with EIDM
2021-10-14 advocates africa evidence week 2021 events evidence informs learns news
Africa Evidence Week 2021: Emerging EIDM leader_Charity Chisoro: why I fell in love with EIDM
Ms Charity Chisoro in conversation with the Africa Evidence Network secretariat on why she fell in love with evidence-informed decision-making (EIDM).
Watch
Africa Evidence Week 2021: Emerging EIDM leader_Edward Kayongo: why I fell in love with EIDM
2021-10-14 advocates africa evidence week 2021 events evidence informs learns news
Africa Evidence Week 2021: Emerging EIDM leader_Edward Kayongo: why I fell in love with EIDM
Mr Edward Kayongo in conversation with the Africa Evidence Network secretariat on why he fell in love with evidence-informed decision-making (EIDM).
Watch
Africa Evidence Week 2021: Emerging EIDM leader_Eucharia Nwaichi: why I fell in love with EIDM
2021-10-14 advocates africa evidence week 2021 events evidence informs learns news
Africa Evidence Week 2021: Emerging EIDM leader_Eucharia Nwaichi: why I fell in love with EIDM
Ms Eucharia Nwaichi in conversation with the Africa Evidence Network secretariat on why she fell in love with evidence-informed decision-making (EIDM).
Watch
Africa Evidence Week 2021: Emerging EIDM leader_Gloria Anderson: why I fell in love with EIDM
2021-10-14 advocates africa evidence week 2021 events evidence informs learns news
Africa Evidence Week 2021: Emerging EIDM leader_Gloria Anderson: why I fell in love with EIDM
Ms Gloria Anderson in conversation with the Africa Evidence Network secretariat on why she fell in love with evidence-informed decision-making (EIDM).
Watch
Africa Evidence Week 2021: Emerging EIDM leader_Lesedi Matlala: why I fell in love with EIDM
2021-10-14 advocates africa evidence week 2021 events evidence informs learns news
Africa Evidence Week 2021: Emerging EIDM leader_Lesedi Matlala: why I fell in love with EIDM
Mr Lesedi Matlala in conversation with the Africa Evidence Network secretariat on why he fell in love with evidence-informed decision-making (EIDM).
Watch
Africa Evidence Week 2021: Emerging EIDM leader_Nain Mirabel Yuh: why I fell in love with EIDM
2021-10-14 advocates africa evidence week 2021 events evidence informs learns news
Africa Evidence Week 2021: Emerging EIDM leader_Nain Mirabel Yuh: why I fell in love with EIDM
Ms. Nain Mirabel Yuh in conversation with the Africa Evidence Network secretariat on why she fell in love with evidence-informed decision-making (EIDM).
Watch
Africa Evidence Week 2021: Emerging EIDM leader_Precious Motha: why I fell in love with EIDM
2021-10-14 advocates africa evidence week 2021 events evidence informs learns news
Africa Evidence Week 2021: Emerging EIDM leader_Precious Motha: why I fell in love with EIDM
Ms Precious Motha in conversation with the Africa Evidence Network secretariat on why she fell in love with evidence-informed decision-making (EIDM).
Watch
Africa Evidence Week 2021: Emerging EIDM leader_Ribgobert Pambe: why I fell in love with EIDM
2021-10-14 advocates africa evidence week 2021 events evidence informs learns news
Africa Evidence Week 2021: Emerging EIDM leader_Ribgobert Pambe: why I fell in love with EIDM
Mr Ribgobert Pambe in conversation with the Africa Evidence Network secretariat on why she fell in love with evidence-informed decision-making (EIDM).
Watch
Africa Evidence Week 2021: How is #AfricaEvidenceWeek2021 going?
2021-10-14 advocates africa evidence week 2021 events evidence informs learns news
Africa Evidence Week 2021: How is #AfricaEvidenceWeek2021 going?
The operations manager of the Africa Evidence Network, Siziwe Ngcwabe, shares her experience of #AfricaEvidenceWeek2021. Do you want to join the celebration of evidence-use in Africa? Jump onto Twitte...
Watch
Africa Evidence Week 2021: How to participate in Africa Evidence Week 2021
2021-10-14 advocates africa evidence week 2021 events evidence informs learns news
Africa Evidence Week 2021: How to participate in Africa Evidence Week 2021
Africa Evidence Leadership Award 2021 winner Diana Warira shares the best ways to join the celebration of #AfricaEvidenceWeek2021.
Watch
Summary Baseline Report: Status of Sanitation in Ghana and the Role of CSOs in Policy Processes
2021-09-15 advocates africa evidence week 2021 event informs learns news
Summary Baseline Report: Status of Sanitation in Ghana and the Role of CSOs in Policy Processes
In June 2019, CLEAR AA and Twende Mbele worked with Ghana Monitoring and Evaluation Forum to commission a baseline study on collaboration between Civil Society and Government for improved accountabili...
Open Link More Details
AEN June 2021 Newsletter
2021-06-18 advocates africa-evidence-week-2019 connects informs learns news newsletter
AEN June 2021 Newsletter
This June, expect to read about Kenyan policy-makers' leading strides in using evidence to reform education policies for the benefit of girls in the public school system. Fitting for youth month celeb...
Open Link More Details
AEN May 2021 newsletter
2021-05-20 advocates africa-evidence connects informs learns news
AEN May 2021 newsletter
May is Africa month! Enjoy this month's edition of the AEN newsletter as we kick off with celebrating the successful launch of the Academy of Sciences in Malawi, read on one more story of change from ...
Open Link More Details
AEN Newsletter - April 2021
2021-04-20 advocates africa-evidence-leadership-award connects informs learns news newsletter
AEN Newsletter - April 2021
Look forward to the April 2021 AEN newsletter, as we continue to celebrate the 2021 Africa Evidence Leadership Award (AELA) winner. Further afield we share the Centres for Disease Control and Preventi...
Open Link More Details
AELA 2021: The Culmination of a Passion that Became a Career
2021-04-15 advocates africa-evidence-leadership-award connects informs learns news
AELA 2021: The Culmination of a Passion that Became a Career
Diana Warira makes a presentation on the role of communication in enhancing the use of demographic dividend research in Africa at The Wilson Center in April 2018. Photo copyright: The Wilson Center ...
Continue Reading
Manifeste sur le développement des capacités à la prise de décision fondée sur les preuves (PDFP) en Afrique
2021-03-30 advocates africa-evidence connects informs learns news
Manifeste sur le développement des capacités à la prise de décision fondée sur les preuves (PDFP) en Afrique
Dans le cadre de la conférence biennale du Réseau africain des données probantes (AEN), intitulé « EVIDENCE 2020 ONLINE », un groupe de travail composé de membres de l'AEN a été formé en avril/mai 202...
Open Link More Details
MANIFESTO ON CAPACITY DEVELOPMENT FOR EIDM IN AFRICA
2021-03-10 advocates africa evidence connects informs learns news
MANIFESTO ON CAPACITY DEVELOPMENT FOR EIDM IN AFRICA
As one of the outputs collectively worked on during EVIDENCE 2020 ONLINE, the Africa Evidence Network (AEN) Manifesto on Capacity Development for Evidence-Informed Decision-Making in Africa represents...
Open Link More Details
CLEAR-AA Wits Vacancies
2019-11-13 advocates connects evaluation informs learns monitoring news vacancy
CLEAR-AA Wits Vacancies
The Centre for Learning on Evaluation and Results for Anglophone Africa (CLEAR-AA) at University of the Witwatersrand (Wits) has the following vacancies: 1)  “Young and Emerging Eva...
Continue Reading
Evidence & Policy in Africa: Welcome to the AEN!
2014-07-15 advocates blog events evidence informs learns news
Evidence & Policy in Africa: Welcome to the AEN!
  As an African traveling overseas one is bound to encounter some of the many misconceptions the rest of the world seems to have developed about Africa. Africa might be a country, or it might ...
Continue Reading